Awards Archive for December, 2007

Oscar Competitor Perspective

It’s a funny thing… we all want to believe that awards season has a basic legitimacy of “you vote for what you like,” but it just isn’t that way. It’s like finding someone you’re attracted to… it doesn’t always make so much sense on paper, but it is what it is.
The two $100 million movies in the race, American Gangster and Hairspray, are well liked by many, but as the critics’ top tens are showing – placing them, so far, at 28 and 39 – respect is a different achievement. Instinctively, it sometimes seems to me like both are still right in the middle of the race, but objectively, nope.
There is nothing wrong with Sweeney Todd‘s opening weekend or Atonement‘s limited release. But suddenly, Atonement is being passed by Juno (albeit on more screens) and one wonders whether they have been a little too precious with their high-toned movie. Sweeney is well off the Dreamgirls opening pace and with two holiday weekends, $40 million is about the top the film can hope for by the start of the new year. Will that be read as a solid start or a dangerous middle road, with any hopes for a $100 million gross completely dependent on Oscar?
The big advantage that Atonement still holds is that it is getting the critical support (#7 on the current Top Ten chart). Sweeney isn’t doing bad there either (#13).
But we are still swimming in the same big pool. There Will Be Blood continues to have an odd advantage by not being seen. The Diving Bell & The Butterfly, Into The Wild, and Juno remain in the “right” position to grab somewhat unexpected BP slots, as No Country For Old Men and Michael Clayton go into Christmas as the two most locked-in films… with Atonement and Sweeney Todd a little bit weaker than before.
The thing about Now is that there is almost nothing that really can be done about any of it. The movies are in charge now. Perception of things like box office wil be noticed, but primarily as a confirmation of viability.
There are two objctive standards that seem to hold at this time of the year. The first is that the film needs to be over $15 million gross if it was released before December and needs to appear on its way to success if released slowly in December. The second is that all five films are likely to be in the Top Ten chart’s top 21. We have seen films from outside that group move in as more lists are compiled. But we have never gone outside of the Top 21 for a nominee since we’ve been doing the charts. And the range has become smaller in the last couple of years. American Gangster and 3:10 To Yuma both have the potential to still crack the Top 20. We’ll see.
In the meanwhile, Gurus o’ Gold’s Top 5 are in the Top Tens’ top 13… a few in that group are likely to be fiscally blocked – Diving Bell is a problem that way – and things will change as the next 100+ charts come in… and as the grosses roll in over the next week.
In other words, the season remains the same…



I’m not sure that I have made this point clearly…
The WGA will not shut down the Oscars.
There is a world of difference between fucking with a 100


Not Sure How Well Reported This AMPAS Response Was

Message regarding the Academy and the WGA
(posted 12/18/07, 11 a.m. PT):
To the members of the Academy:
Some reports in the press have stated that the Academy had been denied a waiver by the WGA that would have allowed Guild writers to work on the telecast of the 80th Annual Academy Awards. In fact, the Academy has not requested such a waiver, nor has the Guild told the Academy whether such a request would or wouldn’t be viewed favorably.
As it does each year, the Academy recently requested from the WGA a waiver in connection with any film clips and excerpts from past Oscar telecasts that might be shown on the upcoming Academy Awards telecast. The Academy was informed last night that the Guild would not grant that waiver, stating that to do so would not advance the Guild’s goals in its current efforts to achieve a collective bargaining agreement. This decision affects only the conditions under which we may use such material, not our ability to do so.
The Academy remains committed to presenting its Awards on February 24, and will continue to work with all parties to achieve that goal.

1 Comment »

Oops, They Did It Again

WGA West Statement on Film Independent Spirit Awards
LOS ANGELES — The Writers Guild of America, West (WGAW) has issued the following statement regarding the Independent Spirit Awards:


A rather brilliant move, I think, by Miramax today, sending out hardback copies of No Country For Old Men. It’s not a movie-themed cover. It’s not the cheaper quality paperback that would have cost them at least a few bucks less per unit to send out. It is a move that says, this is a serious book… a film of literary weight… and not just some movie with a lot of killing.
It is also a tacit call for us to read. Dear God! Read!!!
Then there was the odd delivery of the day. Shipped by Techincolor, Warners delivered the 2-disc “Special Edition” of Harry Potter & The Order of the Phoenix. There were Warning letters from both WB and WIP about the responsibility of getting screeners… but what we got was the same DVD that is every story in America… even the grocery stores!
Even wilder, this disc has a digital copy included. It’s actually quite smart, though the download doesn’t work on Apple or, naturally, on iPods. I think this is a part of the future of DVD sales… including a digital version of the film, but specifically for your iPod or iPhone or whatever portable device you own.
But the screener warning letter tickled me as I got, very pleasantly, a shipment that could just as easily come from
Also landing today… The Golden Compass. Still pending… There WIll Be Blood, Sweeney Todd, and I Am Legend



What to make of the SAG nominations?
Airplanes? Origami? Another Yuletide log on the fire?


20 Weeks – Damaged Frontal Globe



The Quick Version

The Globes, as usual, found a way to discount their significance.
Not only did they choose 7 dramas to reward with nominations, they didn


There Will Be Fighting

I guess I will throw my twenty cents into the tempest in this week


BFCA Piles On

I don


Sweeney Sampling

If you want to have a sampling of the entire Sweeney Todd soundtrack, 30 seconds per song, you can find it on the page, where the pre-order for the Dec 18 release of the album is up and running.

1 Comment »

Landing In NY

More no-surprises.
The closest thing to interesting was the choice of Julie Christie and the choice to honor last year


Critic Time

The big parade of critics groups


National Bored of Reviewing Dinner Plans

Yes… it’s that time again… and NBR still loves having dinner with celebrities they pretty much know will be in the awards race…
That said, I have to admit, it’s a lot more like HFPA whoring this time… no really extreme missteps just to get celebs to show.
Notably left out were Before The Devil Knows You


I Hate To Be A Dick About It…

I like much of Atonement… enough to recommend the movie to anyone without a penis and to some with one. But to compare it to Dr Zhivago or Reds or even the more-heady-than-meaty The English Patient is capital-I INSANE.
I do think that the nature of the Oscar season will see the film nominated for Best Picture and for another half dozen awards. It is a step up from Pride & Prejudice for all involved. And the first 30 minutes threatens to offer a classic of the form. But the film doesn’t even attempt to match the ambitions of any of the trio of films Anne Thompson is comparing it to… and while at times it matches the fine detail of some of the great Merchant-Ivory films, it doesn’t seem to aspire to the inner monologues of those works when push comes to shove either. 20 minutes less might have rebalanced the film that way… but movies are not horseshoes.
Thank you for your time.


Quote Unquotesee all »

“I really want to see The Irishman. I’ve heard it’s big brother Martin Scorsese’s masterpiece. But I really can’t find the time. The promotion schedule is so tight, there’s no opportunity to see a three and a half-hour movie. But I really want to see it. In 2017, right before Okja’s New York premiere, I had the chance to go to Scorsese’s office, which is in the DGA building. There’s a lovely screening room there, too, with film prints that he’s collected. I talked to him for about an hour. There’s no movie he hasn’t seen, even Korean films. We talked about what he’s seen and his past work. It was a glorious day. I’ve loved his work since I was in college. Who doesn’t? Anyone involved with movies must feel the same way.”
~ Bong Joon-ho

“But okay, I promise you now that if I ever retire again, I’m going to ensure that I can’t walk it back. I’ll post a series of the most disgusting, offensive, outrageous statements you can ever imagine. That way it will be impossible for me to ever be employed again. No one is going to take my calls. No one is going to want to be seen with me. Oh, it will be scorched earth. I will have torched everything. I’m going to flame out in the most legendary fashion.”
~ Steven Soderbergh