Sean
O'Connell WBTV-News 3 |
1 | Good
Night, And Good Luck | 2 | Batman
Begins | 3 | The
Upside of Anger | 4 | Munich |
5 | Walk
the Line | 6 | Enron:
The Smartest Guys in the Room | 7 | Charlie
& The Chocolate Factory | 8 | A
History of Violence | 9 | The
Weather Man | 10 | Wallace
& Gromit | | |
|
1 | Oldboy |
2 | The
World | 3 | Tropical
Malady | 4 | Kings
and Queen | 5 | A
History of Violence | 6 | The
Ice Harvest | 7 | Palindromes |
8 | Kung
Fu Hustle | 9 | Land
of the Dead | 10 | The
Corpse Bride | |
| | | |
Andrew
Sarris NY
Observer | 1 | A
History of Violence | 2 | 2046 |
3 | Match
Point | 4 | March
of the Penguins | 5 | Saraband |
6 | Proof |
7 | The
Squid & the Whale | 8 | Sin
City | 9 | Look
at Me | 10 | Breakfast
on Pluto | | |
B.
Ruby Rich SF Bay Guardian |
1 | Brokeback
Mountain | 2 | Darwin's
Nightmare | 3 | Good
Night, and Good Luck | 4 | A
History of Violence | 5 | The
Holy GIrl | 6 | My
Summer of Love | 7 | Mysterious
Skin | 8 | Paradise
Now | 9 | Tropical
Malady | 10 | The
World | |
| | | |
Kevin
Laforest Montreal Film Journal |
1 | A
History of Violence | 2 | Melinda
and Melinda | 3 | Manderlay |
4 | Sin
City | 5 | Me
and You and Everyone We Know | 6 | Oldboy |
7 | Capote |
8 | Grizzly
Man | 9 | Elizabethtown |
10 | Munich |
| |
Chuck
Stephens SF
Bay Guardian |
1 | 2046 |
2 | A
History of Violence | 3 | Land
of the Dead | 4 | Last
Days | 5 | Memories
of Murder | 6 | Nobody
Knows | 7 | Pulse |
8 | Save
the Green Planet | 9 | Tropical
Malady | 10 | The
World | |
| | | |
Chris
Hewitt St Paul Pioneer Press |
1 | Walk
the Line | 2 | Murderball |
3 | Millions |
4 | Brokeback
Mountain | 5 | The
Devil's Rejects | 6 | Jesus
is Magic | 7 | Land
of the Dead | 8 | Oldboy |
9 | Sin
City | 10 | King
Kong | | |
Susan
Gehard SF
Bay Guardian |
1 | Cache |
2 | Me
and You and Everyone We Know | 3 | Turtles
Can Fly | 4 | The
World | 5 | Tony
Takitani | 6 | Paradise
Now | 7 | Jarhead |
8 | Tropical
Malady | 9 | Crash |
10 | Rize |
|
| | | |
Patrick
McGavin Chicago
Tribune | 1 | The
New World | 2 | Kings
and Queen | 3 | 2046 |
4 | A
History of Violence | 5 | The
Holy Girl | 6 | Match
Point | 7 | The
Beat That My Heart Skipped | 8 | The
World | 9 | Tropical
Malady | 10 | Broken
Flowers | | |
Johnnie
Ray Huston SF
Bay Guardian |
| 1 | Pulse |
| 2 | Cache |
| 3 | A
History of Violence | | 4 | Land
of the Dead | | 5 | Tropical
Malady | | 6 | Whisky |
| 7 | Grizzly
Man | | 8 | Nobody
Knows | | 9 | Mysterious
Skin | | 10 | Innocence |
|