MCN Columnists
David Poland

By David Poland poland@moviecitynews.com

20 Weeks To Oscar: Nomination Morning

For an unpredictable season, this was pretty predictable.

The niche movies that settled early – Lady Bird, Get Out, Call Me By Your Name – got in. The rest – I, Tonya, The Big Sick, Mudbound – did not. Phantom Thread, which is in so many ways a traditional Academy film, was the surprise tag on the day. A lot of people had written off Darkest Hour, but it got the Best Picture nod, though not a surprise in other categories that would suggest it could possibly cause an upset.

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, The Shape of Water, Dunkirk, and The Post were widely expected nominees.

So now what? Probably not much, in terms of big surprises.

It’s very easy to imagine:
Best Picture: 3 Billboards
Best Director: Guillermo del Toro
Best Actress: Frances McDormand
Best Actor: Gary Oldman
Best Supporting Actor: Sam Rockwell
Best Supporting Actress: Allison Janney
Best Original Screenplay: Three Billboards
Best Adapted Screenplay: Call Me By Your Name

Things could swing in a couple of those categories, but not by much. It’s the same list you would have expected before the nominations this morning.

On the other hand… Three Billboards is under attack from the PC police.

Universal will keep pushing Get Out hard. Focus got “do-over” opportunities for their two Best Picture nominees that many felt would not have gotten their BP slots, Phantom Thread and Darkest Hour. Warner Bros isn’t abandoning Dunkirk. And at Searchlight, they have two children, one the more cerebral (3BB) and one more of the heart, The Shape of Water, which as the frontrunner for Best Director has a legit chance of becoming the BP winner too. (And Lady Bird isn’t a dead issue to win BP either.)

Nomination morning is reset morning.

How can the consultants, publicists, and marketers turn the corner and make their movie the movie of the moment, a film of importance, a film of higher value, a film you love and shouldn’t be afraid to imagine winning?

Of course, the easy assumption is that things are now baked in an won’t change. And that may well end up being the case.

But the season is still soft.

This is when the hard-boiled will of the team behind any film can rise and change the game.

Three Billboards needs Frances McDormand and Woody Harrelson out there explaining why the movie is about something profound and about moving forward, not about lingering in the pain of the moment (however long it has lasted).

Focus didn’t really explain why Darkest Hour was so much of the moment when they released this film. They could do this now.

Phantom Thread relied heavily on the shoulders of Vicky Krieps and Mark Bridges up until now… if that changes and PTA is also willing to have them explain the film a bit more, the ball can be moved.

Dunkirk‘s unique place in filmmaking can be further exploited.

Universal has done great work in positioning Get Out as more than a horror comedy (though this is probably the top of the mountain).

Context is in order for The Shape of Water… a movie about movies… Oscar loves that shit. (Also, true here.)

Lady Bird needs to stay solid and emphasize that it is about the future of a young woman… thus, the future of all women.

I am a fan of Call Me By Your Name and The Post, but neither is winning this year.

In meetings all over town, the question of whether Phase II will be a war or a love letter is being determined. Me? I think the door is open just wide enough for people to come out fighting. But we shall see… about this time next week, just before every single person alive is honored in Santa Barbara, we will know.

7 Responses to “20 Weeks To Oscar: Nomination Morning”

  1. The Pope says:

    While I agree Call Me By Your Name will win Adapted Screenplay, I think Lady Bird will win Original. For the simple reason that for all its inventiveness and (ticklish) offensiveness, Three Billboards, like all of McDonagh’s work, exists solely within a conceit, a construct, a frame of McDonagh’s impression of mid-America.

    Lady Bird feels authentic. Ask anyone who has been through a Sacred Heart school and they will say the same thing. Yes, Gerwig’s screenplay is charming and warm and drizzled with the clichés of final year and going to the prom, but it always feels that the characters have actually lived in real life.

    For me, Three Billboards… doesn’t deliver that experience.

  2. lockedcut says:

    Picture will be won as always by least divisive film benefitting from an instant runoff, so probably can easily eliminate from contention 3 billboards, phantom thread, and Dunkirk.

    I’m rooting for something bizarre but it’s be nice to see del toro join the other two amigos.

  3. Sam E says:

    Moonlight and Birdman were the least divisive films nominated for best picture?

  4. palmtree says:

    More fatal to 3BB than the so-called PC police is that the movie isn’t very good. I mean, well-made and well-acted and well-plotted, but the substance of the movie is a bit shallow. I mean, if they need to explain to people that the movie is really about something profound, well then…it might just mean the movie isn’t.

  5. Stephen Barrow says:

    I’m disappointed for Martin McDonagh (as director), Judi Dench, Armie Hammer and Michael Stuhlbarg (if these two “split their vote” how didn’t Harrelson and Rockwell?). I’m very happy for Lesley Manville (although we haven’t had Phantom Thread in the UK yet). I’m a bit surprised by Denzel, Meryl and Christopher Plummer (did they need or even want these noms?). I have a feeling Oscar will revert to what used to be expected and Del Toro and Shape of Water will win (we haven’t had that one yet either!)

  6. Bob Burns says:

    now name the publicists running the campaigns behind all these films, so we know who to blame for the negative campaigns.

  7. Greg says:

    Still holding out hope for Laurie Metcalf.

Quote Unquotesee all »

“Because of my relative candor on Twitter regarding why I quit my day job, my DMs have overflowed with similar stories from colleagues around the globe. These peeks behind the curtains of film festivals, venues, distributors and funding bodies weren’t pretty. Certain dismal patterns recurred (and resonated): Boards who don’t engage with or even understand their organization’s artistic mission and are insensitive to the diverse neighborhood in which their organization’s venue is located; incompetent founders and/or presidents who create only obstacles, never solutions; unduly empowered, Trumpian bean counters who chip away at the taste and experiences that make organizations’ cultural offerings special; expensive PR teams that don’t bring to the table a bare-minimum familiarity with the rich subcultural art form they’re half-heartedly peddling as “product”; nonprofit arts organizations for whom art now ranks as a distant-second goal behind profit.”
~ Eric Allen Hatch

To me, Hunter S. Thompson was a hero. His early books were great, but in many ways, his life and career post–Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail is a cautionary tale for authors. People expected him to be high and drunk all the time and play that persona, and he stuck with that to the end, and I don’t think it was good for him. I always sort of feel mixed emotions when I hear that people went and hung out with Hunter and how great it was to get high with Hunter. The fact is the guy was having difficulty doing any sustained writing at all for years probably because so many quote, unquote, “friends” wanted to get high with him … There was a badly disappointed romantic there. I mean, that great line, “This is where the wave broke, the tide rolled back … ” This was a guy that was hurt and disappointed and very bitter about things, and it made his writing beautiful, and also with that came a lot of pain.
~ Anthony Bourdain