The 2012 Top Tens: Updated

You can see the individual lists here or click on the individual critic name for their list.

Rank Last Chart Top Tens PolandAndersonCrouseSchreiberHortonKatzGerebenGriersonStarnesHernandez Votes Total
1 1 Zero Dark Thirty
 1 1 * 1 7 8 9 80 601.5
2 2 Master, The
 4 * * 2 7 3 3 2 71 461.5
3 3 Moonrise Kingdom
 * 4 66 409.5
4 4 Amour
 1 3 9 5 57 379.0
5 5 Lincoln
 6 * 10 4 5 56 378.5
6 6 Beasts of the Southern Wild
 4 2 48 314.0
7 7 Holy Motors
 10 1 42 268.5
8 8 Argo
 4 40 234.5
9 9 Silver Linings Playbook
 * 31 166.5
10 10 Django Unchained
 * 26 162.0
11 13 Looper
 * 24 126.0
12 11 Life of Pi
 5 24 118.0
13 12 This is not a Film
 7 * 5 21 117.0
14 14 Once Upon a Time in Anatolia
 * 3 21 113.5
15 16 Skyfall
 * 20 107.0
16 15 Deep Blue Sea, The
 4 19 92.5
17 20 Turin Horse, The
 2 * 1 3 11 90.5
18 17 Dark Knight Rises, The
 * 18 77.0
19 18 Rust and Bone
 3 6 14 75.5
20 19 Sessions, The
 * 3 6 14 74.5
21 Grey, The
 5 14 69.5
22 Cabin in the Woods, The
 13 67.0
23 Oslo, August 31st
 6 14 66.0
24 Perks of Being a Wallflower
 8 16 63.0
25 Cloud Atlas
 10 12 61.0
26 Avengers, The
 6 11 60.0
27 Les Miserables
 1 10 56.5
28 Anna Karenina
 1 10 55.5
29 How to Survive a Plague
 8 13 54.5
30 Searching for Sugar Man
 * 10 51.0
0 Magic Mike
 11 50.0
Cosmopolis
 3 9 10 48.5
Gatekeepers, The
 7 10 48.0
Tabu
 7 9 48.0
It's Such a Beautiful Day
 5 7 48.0
Imposter, The
 9 8 46.0
Kid With the Bike, The
 6 9 45.5
Flight
 4 10 45.0
Elena
 2 5 39.0
Killer Joe
 5 10 9 38.5
Wuthering Heights
 6 37.5
Comedy, The
 8 37.0
Lonliest Planet, The
 8 37.0
Damsels in Distress
 8 36.0
Take This Waltz
 9 10 9 33.5
Bernie
 10 * 8 33.5
Impossible, The
 * 7 6 32.5
Compliance
 4 8 30.0
Stories We Tell
 * 4 29.5
Barbara
 6 28.0
Sister
 6 23.0
Safety Not Guaranteed
 5 23.0
Headhunters
 8 4 23.0
Your Sister's Sister
 5 22.0
Margaret
 * 4 22.0
Waiting Room, The
 3 22.0
Middle of Nowhere
 4 21.0
Haywire
 4 20.5
Monsieur Lazhar
 7 3 20.0
Footnote
 4 19.0
Keep the Lights On
 5 18.5
House I Live In
 3 18.5
Killing Them Softly
 5 18.0
Kill List
 5 18.0
A Separation
 2 17.0
In the Family
 2 17.0
21 Jump Street
 5 16.0
Only the Young
 4 16.0
Arbitrage
 6 3 15.5
Raid, The
 5 15.0
Beloved
 4 15.0
Goodbye, First Love
 3 15.0
This is Forty
 4 14.5
Oki's Movie
 3 14.5
End of Watch
 3 14.5
Wreck-It Ralph
 4 14.0
Room 237
 6 3 14.0
Paperboy, The
 3 14.0
Alps
 2 14.0
Polisse
 1 2 14.0
Two Years at Sea
 2 14.0
A Simple Life
 2 13.5
Queen of Versailles, The
 5 13.0
Al Weiwei: Never Sorry
 7 5 13.0
Ted
 9 3 13.0
Jiro Dreams of Sushi
 3 12.5
Girl Walk All Day
 10 4 12.0
Color Wheel
 4 12.0
Invisible War, The
 3 12.0
Not Fade Away
 2 12.0
Sightseers
 2 12.0
Almayer's Folly
 2 11.5
Perfect Sense
 5 2 11.5
Frankenweenie
 4 11.0
Jeff, Who Lives at Home
 4 11.0
Day He Arrives, The
 3 11.0
Where Do We Go Now?
 2 11.0
Farewell My Queen
 2 2 11.0
Central Park Five, The
 2 11.0
To Rome with Love
 * 2 10.5
Marina Abramovic: The Artist is Present
 2 10.0
Attenberg
 2 10.0
Dark Horse
 2 9.5
God Bless America
 2 9.0
Ruby Sparks
 2 8.5
Detachment