MCN Columnists
Douglas Pratt

By Douglas Pratt Pratt@moviecitynews.com

Hannah Montana and Miley Cyrus: Best of Both Worlds Concert

I am such a 3-D junkie that the moment I obtained the Walt Disney Studios Home Entertainment 2-Disc Extended Edition release, Hannah Montana and Miley Cyrus Best of Both Worlds Concert, I tore it open with a lustful glee that would not have been equaled had Cyrus herself been sitting next to me on the couch, offering me the sequins on her miniskirt.

The 3-D program appears on the second platter and the standard version appears on the first platter. The 2008 production runs 82 minutes and begins with rehearsal and backstage footage (not in 3-D) before moving on to the concert. Thereafter, there are occasional cuts back to the offstage footage, but they become fewer and fewer as the program progresses. In that nothing needs to be done to enhance the excitement the fans are experiencing simply attending the concert, the choreography is not elaborate and the stage production is fairly basic. Ironically, the viewer is more aware of this because of the attention given to the rehearsals in the opening segment. For each song, there will be one or two mildly complicated moves punctuating a repetitious pattern where Cyrus skips around the stage a bit, advances onto the causeway that extends into the audience, sings and waves a little, and then retreats back to the stage. A few fireworks go off here and there, enormous video screens underscore the action on the stage, and there is enough basic decoration to convey a sense of importance to the event without challenging its profit margins. The first portion of the concert is taken up with the songs made familiar in the Disney TV show that features Cyrus in her clever dual personality (she’s a ‘normal’ teenager who keeps her life as a ‘rock star’ secret), and she performs them in a blonde wig, using the Montana character. The songs speak to this same duality and the conflicts of adolescence that it deftly reflects. After an appearance by the increasingly popular Disney boy band, The Jonas Brothers, Cyrus does a costume change offstage and doffs the wig, to return as her ‘real’ self, with somewhat more mature songs that suggest, rather pointedly, the direction she wishes to take both her persona and her career.

On the first platter, the show is available in both widescreen format, with an aspect ratio of about 1.85:1 and an accommodation for enhanced 16:9 playback, and in full screen format, adding nothing to the top or bottom of the image and losing a lot from the sides. The color transfer is sharp and unaffected by the stage lighting. The 5.1-channel Dolby Digital sound is solid, with some rear channel activity and plenty of power if you feel like pumping the volume. There are optional English subtitles, and a special feature segment that brings up just the songs, with karaoke-style subtitling. There are also two deleted numbers, one featuring theJonas Brothers running 3 minutes and one with Cyrus in her Cyrus incarnation, also running 3 minutes. Additionally, there is a decent 12-minute featurette, showing Cyrus poking around the stage set and talking about the concert (she is part of that maddening vowel shift sweeping America that has changed the pronunciation of ‘tour’ to ‘taur’), her outfits (she pronounces ‘jewelry’ as ‘jolry’) and her schedule leading up to the concert, and including a few quick clips of the Jonas Brothers talking about their participation.

The second platter has just the 3-D version of the concert, again in letterboxed format or full screen format, with no special features other than the optional English subtitling. There are four sets of red/blue glasses included as a jacket insert. They subdue almost all of the colors, but it’s worth it. The 3-D has a tendency to make everything seems smaller, but the perspectives are incredible, and every time Cyrus jaunts down that causeway, you feel like you are hovering just a few feet away. The best angle is from the drums platform, where the entire stage is laid out below and extending, along with the audience, into the distance, and the best segment is the ‘slow song’ that Cyrus (as herself) sings, because the editing and camera movement calm down and you really get a chance to savor the effect within a single shot. But there are also times when the microphone gets thrust toward the camera-and one squeal moment when a guitarist tosses his pic right at the lens-or when one camera captures another on a boom, looming over the crowd and Cyrus like a huge serpent, and there is confetti, the fireworks and all of the other thrills that are so much more tantalizing in 3-D than they could ever hope to be in yesterday’s 2-D.

With video playback technology finally maturing to a level equivalent with film, 3-D in full color cannot be that far off. Many people complain that movies now aren’t what they once were and that nothing new ever seems to be coming out, but in reality, the party is just getting started, and pretty soon, 3-D programs are going to jettison their own toylike trappings just like Cyrus, and take on the world as legitimate entertainment.

August 14, 2008

– by Douglas Pratt

Douglas Pratt’s DVD-Laser Disc Newsletter is published monthly.
For a free sample, call (516)594-9304 or go to his website at www.DVDLaser.com

Comments are closed.

The Ultimate DVD Geek

Quote Unquotesee all »

“Yes, yes, yes. Now I am also the producer on Jean-Luc’s films, so I need to raise the money. Yes, there are two projects in preparation with the pretext of virtual reality. We are beginning with two approaches: we can either do or undo VR. Maybe we will undo it more than we do VR, because thinking about VR leads to the opposite of VR. Is there concrete imagination in virtual reality? For me, cinema is concrete imagination because it’s made with the real and uses it. VR, virtual reality, is totally the opposite of that, but it might be interesting to use this and then to destroy it. No, we’ll see, we’ll see. First, it’s just an idea of a beginning. There is a forest to cross, and we are just at the beginning of the forest. The first step is development. As they say in business, first there is development and research. We have to develop somehow an idea for the film; I won’t say a script, but to see what we can do with this system, and what we can undo with this system.”
~ Fabrice Aragno On Godard’s Next Projects

“Why put it in a box? This is the number one problem I have—by the way it’s a fair question, I’m not saying that—with this kind of festival situation is that there’s always this temptation to classify the movie immediately and if you look at it—and I’ve tried to warn my fellow jurors of this—directors and movie critics are the worst people to judge movies! Directors are always thinking, “I could do that.” Critics are always saying, “This part of the movie is like the 1947 version and this part…” And it’s like, “Fuck! Just watch the movie and try and absorb it and not compare it to some other fucking movie and put it in a box!” So I think the answer’s both and maybe neither, I don’t know. That’s for you to see and criticize me for or not.”
~ James Gray