MCN Blogs
David Poland

By David Poland

Oddball Anti-BBM Winning Stat Of The Day

This is the kind of stat that I don’t really believe in, but…
When was the last time a film won Best Picture without being nominated for Best Editing?
25 years ago, Ordinary People did it.
Yes, every film that won Best Picture, even Driving Miss Daisy, got an editing nomination since then

30 Responses to “Oddball Anti-BBM Winning Stat Of The Day”

  1. Melquiades says:

    It would appear only Crash and Munich have a shot at the prize if this stat is to be taken seriously.

  2. palmtree says:

    I’d like to also mention BM was snubbed in the technical categories. Anne Hathaway’s hair alone should get a nomination in its own category.
    Seriously though, thanks for the stat. Strangely the phenomenon is “recent.” In 1975 and 1978, Godfather II and Annie Hall won respectively without getting an editing nod (and who could say they didn’t deserve them!).

  3. Bruce says:

    Oh no. You’re going to make the BBM’ers even more nervous now. Here it comes.

  4. waterbucket says:

    omg, I’m so scared. barf.

  5. Josh says:

    You can’t just take stats that support your position seriously. It doesn’t work like that. Instead of talking down the hard and firm facts why not just say “BBM will break the mold”?

  6. ArchiveGuy says:

    As long as we’re throwing out stats, Dave…
    (1) When was the last time a film with only 5 nominations won Best Picture? (hint: even farther back than 1980)
    (2) How many times has the Best Picture with the fewest nominations gone on to win the Oscar? (hint: even less often those Pics that won without an Editing nod)
    Dream on, Dear Dave…

  7. Richard Nash says:

    Driving Miss Daisy is the worst Oscar winner of the past 35 years.
    I really think someone read the wrong card.

  8. Tcolors says:

    David Poland said “(quote)When people start trying to rationalize how some

  9. bipedalist says:

    Please. What is he trying to say? Jesus, Munich getting a nod is like when they nominated Godfather III out of politeness. Godfather III incidentally was nominated for SEVEN Oscars! Won none of course. Now only a footnote in Sofia Coppola’s career.

  10. eoguy says:

    Since David opened the BBM discussion, I thought I’d point you over to an article in the Toronto Star today that was rather interestings, and counters David’s claims of a no-prejudice modern society.
    The Article

  11. Sanchez says:

    What’s with the low blows at Godfather 3?

  12. EDouglas says:

    Maybe it’s not too late for Brokeback to reedit… I hope to God that Munich didn’t get an editing nomination… it wouldn’t deserve it unless they edited out about a half hour from the movie

  13. jeffmcm says:

    It did.
    The other 4 were Cinderella Man Constant Gardener, Crash, Walk the Line.

  14. David Poland says:

    It’s an interesting piece.
    But I have NEVER made an argument that society is without bias OR that it is easy to be gay in today’s society or in the 70s OR that it has ever been easy to come out.
    It seems that people who want to spin my ideas just keep claimming it though… no matter what I actually say.

  15. Angelus21 says:

    No prejudice society? Where is this utopia? Fantasy land?

  16. Wayman_Wong says:

    If you want to prove something, you can usually find a stat to prove it. Wanna hear another ”oddball” statistic? Apparently, no Best Picture nominee that’s set in L.A., the home of many Oscar voters, has ever won Best Picture. Examples: ”Sunset Blvd.,” ”Chinatown,” ”L.A. Confidential,” ”The Aviator.” Now does that mean that ”Crash” won’t win? Who knows?
    Here’s another one that a little more substantive: Eight movies that have won the PGA, the DGA and the Best Picture Golden Globe (for Drama or Comedy/Musical) have gone on to win the Oscar for Best Picture: ”Dances With Wolves,” ” Schindler’s List,” ”Forrest Gump,” ”The English Patient,” ”Titanic,” ”American Beauty,” ”Chicago” and ”Lord of the Rings.” And what’s the latest movie to win the PGA, the DGA and its Golden Globe? ”Brokeback Mountain.”
    Does that mean it’s a shoo-in? No. But I’ll take ”Brokeback’s” odds over any other film.

  17. Wayman_Wong says:

    Thanks to a TriviaChamp at, here’s a list of NINE movies that have won the Best Picture Oscar without a Best Editing nomination:
    ”It Happened One Night”
    ”Life of Emile Zola”
    ”Tom Jones”
    ”A Man for All Seasons”
    ”The Godfather II”
    ”Annie Hall”
    ”Ordinary People”
    Come to think of it, isn’t anyone else surprised that ”Good Night, and Good Luck” didn’t score an Editing nod either? It must’ve taken skill to cut back and forth between the new footage and the archival stuff, and make it look seamless.

  18. KamikazeCamelV2.0 says:

    You’d THINK that wouldn’t you? I’m glad The Constant Gardener got in for Editing though – particially makes up for missing Ralph Feinnes and Cinematography. grrr.
    The reason that the editing snub was curious to me was because it was a duel job with the late Peroni. Usually they go for posthumus techs. However, it really is a silly stat (of which i understand Dave is agreeing with – how come others don’t see that?) because the editors branch aren’t the largest one of AMPAS.
    Can I please put it out there that I was one of the first to be predicting Crash for Best Picture and Director? Cause I was.

  19. Wayman_Wong says:

    By the way, the American Cinema Editors, which give out the Eddies, DID nominate ”Brokeback” in its guild awards. ACE divides movies into dramatic features and comedies/musicals. In the drama category, ACE nominated: ”Brokeback,” ”The Constant Gardener,” ”Crash,” ”Good Night, and Good Luck” and ”Munich.” ”Walk the Line,” which is up for an ACE for comedies/musicals, made the final 5 at the Oscars, and so did ”Cinderella Man.” And they wound up displacing ”Brokeback” and ”Good Night, and Good Luck.”

  20. jeffmcm says:

    In GN&GL, it probably was not very hard at all to cut the archival footage with the newly-shot footage, for the simple fact that they probably shot the new stuff around the old stuff, and had every tool at their hands to make things match.
    Editing is editing.

  21. BluStealer says:

    But isn’t that a sign of “good” editing? What jeff is saying is that anyone can be an editor and it shouldn’t even be a category for awards. “Good Night, Good Luck” is looks seamless because of how well it is done. Everything done well looks easy.

  22. ArchiveGuy says:

    Wayman_Wong: “Million $ Baby” was set in L.A.

  23. Wayman_Wong says:

    ArchiveGuy, could’ve fooled me. There’s nothing about that movie that read L.A. to me. The funny thing is that I first heard that L.A. statistic quoted last year as a reason why ”The Aviator” wouldn’t win. Saw it mentioned on various film chat boards and never saw anyone say that ”Million $ Baby” is set in L.A. You’re the first!

  24. jeffmcm says:

    Blustealer, you didn’t understand what I said. It was said above that GN&GL’s editing was made even more difficult by the process of matching archival footage to new footage. I said that the movie was almost certainly designed – shot, costumed, edited, to fit around the previously existing footage. So while any good movie is well-edited, the editors of that film didn’t really have a hurdle to work around but rather were being accomodated by other aspects of production.

  25. joefitz84 says:

    I don’t think settings play that much into what wins and what doesn’t.

  26. KamikazeCamelV2.0 says:

    But some people like to use that as a way of justifying the fact their their favourite movies did not win.

  27. SaveFarris says:

    M$B was unmistakably set in L.A.
    At least one scene outside the gym shows the Library Tower in the background, and there is discussion about the proximity to Vegas (the fight where Maggie gets ***SPOILER***ed).

  28. jeffmcm says:

    It’s in L.A. but the location is not primary to the plot, as it is in Crash, Short Cuts, Magnolia, etc.

  29. peterv says:

    The editing stat is interesting, but somewhat silly. Another silly historical stat is looking at the number of nominations among best picture winners. In the past 60 years, only three best pics had less than 7 nominations:
    1. Ordinary People (1980)
    2. Annie Hall (1977)
    3. Greatest Show on Earth (1952)

Quote Unquotesee all »

“The word I have fallen in love with lately is ‘Hellenic.’ Greek in its mythology. So while everyone is skewing towards the YouTube generation, here we are making two-and-a-half-hour movies and trying to buck the system. It’s become clear to me that we are never going to be a perfect fit with Hollywood; we will always be the renegade Texans running around trying to stir the pot. Really it’s not provocation for the sake of being provocative, but trying to make something that people fall in love with and has staying power. I think people are going to remember Dragged Across Concrete and these other movies decades from now. I do not believe that they will remember some of the stuff that big Hollywood has put out in the last couple of years. You’ve got to look at the independent space to find the movies that have been really special recently. Even though I don’t share the same world-view as some of my colleagues, I certainly respect the hell out of their movies which are way more fascinating than the stuff coming out of the studio system.”
~ Dallas Sonnier

“My first objective relationship in life was with the camera. I didn’t understand anything but then I realized the camera is my friend. It doesn’t lie to me. It doesn’t manipulate me. It only reports what I’m doing. And therefore, for me to work with a camera and the camera to be directed by an artist, a craftsman, someone who knows what he or she wants, I couldn’t ask for anything more.”
~ Elliot Gould